Why does lead-free solder affect PCB reliability?
The lead-free technology of electronic products is not only related to the printed circuit board problem, but also a system engineering problem. It involves a series of issues such as the performance of copper clad plate (CCL), the production process and technology of printed circuit board, the type and composition of lead-free solder, the welding method and technology of lead-free solder, the performance of components and the inspection methods, specifications and standards of the reliability of lead-free products. Therefore, it is necessary to understand this system engineering from a holistic point of view.
PCB Instant Quote
.my-button {
display: inline-block;
padding: 10px 50px;
font-size: 16px;
text-align: center;
text-decoration: none;
background-color: blue;
color: #fffff0;
border: none;
border-radius: 5px;
font-weight: bold;
cursor: pointer;
box-shadow: 0px 2px 5px rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.3);
transition: background-color 0.3s ease, transform 0.3s ease;
}
.my-button:hover {
background-color: #C23C30;
transform: scale(1.05);
}
This chapter from the electronic products implementation of lead-free proposal, the basic characteristics of lead-free solder, lead-free solder welding characteristics and requirements of the main requirements of electronic components, copper clad plate substrate materials, printed circuit board product substrate and related tests and standards, etc., the implementation of lead-free electronic products are discussed in detail. The purpose is to enable readers to have a more comprehensive understanding of this, in order to facilitate electronic products (including raw materials, components, printed circuit boards, assembly, etc.) manufacturers, especially related engineering and technical personnel, from the overall perspective to understand, research and solve the problem of lead-free electronic products, So that electronic products can smoothly and quickly transition from the lead (tin-lead system) era to the lead-free era.
What Are EU Requirements for Environmental Friendliness?
In the early 1990s, the United States first came up with a standard to limit the benefits of marriage in electronic products. However, because there was no (printed circuit processing and want to solder technology is not mature, there is no live replacement. Coupled with forced restrictions on the lead content of electronic products, will reduce the reliability of electronic products. In the future, some high-end electronic products, such as defense, military, aerospace, aviation or high-reliability fields, or to buy solders containing relaxation. So far, the best tin-silver solder SAC305, although its performance is close to that of tin-lead solder, its reliability is still not as good as that of tin-lead solder.
However, the research work of lead-free has not stopped, and the development progress of substitutes for tin-lead systems has been further strengthened in recent years, and practical tin-silver-copper systems (such as SAC305, Sn-96.5/Ag3.0/C0.5) and tin-copper systems (such as Sn-99.2/Cu0.8) have been successfully developed. The performance and availability of these systems are close to that of tin-lead systems. The conditions and opportunities for lead-free electronic products are approaching maturity.
As a result, the European Union promulgated the RoHS directive (that is, the Directive on the Restriction of the use of Certain Hazardous Components in Electrical and Electronic Equipment) and the WEEE Directive (that is, the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Directive) on February 13, 2003, and officially implemented on July 1, 2006. Then, China has also formulated the "Measures for the Prevention and Control of pollution of Electronic Information Products" and the "Measures for the Management of pollution of electronic products" and other relevant legislation (draft) work (implemented on March 1, 2007) to control the environmental pollution and harm caused by the processing, assembly, use and waste of domestic electronic products. And encourage and promote electronic products to take the road of green cleaner production and sustainable development. The promulgation and implementation of these directives marked the arrival of the lead-free era.
The core content of the two EU directives :D from July 1, 2006, new electrical and electronic products placed on the market should be free of lead, mercury, hexvalent chromium, polyphthalate (PBB) and polyphthalate (PBDE) these six harmful substances, as resin flame retardant bisphenol A (TBBPA) is not included; The manufacturer of electronic products is responsible for the collection, sorting and treatment of waste electrical and electronic equipment for recycling, and bears the associated costs; 3 The organization dealing with waste electrical and electronic equipment shall obtain the permission of the competent authority (department), and the unit dealing with waste electrical and electronic equipment shall comply with the requirements of Annex III of the WEEE Directive when storing and disposing of waste electrical and electronic equipment.
As can be seen from the above two instructions, in the printed circuit board (or copper clad plate substrate), one of the most important components of electronic products, the largest amount of flame retardant 1-4 O bisphenol A (TBBPA), after long-term practice and repeated scientific tests have shown that it is harmless, not among the harmful substances. Then, the European Union confirmed in the latest revised risk assessment report in December 2004 that "quadruple bisphenol A" is safe for human health, and the environmental risk assessment was completed in 2005. In July 2005, at the "Green Production of copper clad plates and printed Circuits and the Application of Quadruple Bisphenol A Seminar" in Shenzhen, China. Dr. Raymond B Dawson, president of the Australian Institute for Science and the Environment (BSEF), reiterated this view, noting that the continued use of tetrabisphenol A was permitted. From the current situation, the impact on the multilayer printed circuit board or copper clad plate is a lead-free solder problem rather than a halogen-free flame retardant problem. Therefore, lead-free is currently and in the future to promote the change and development of copper clad plate materials, printed circuit board production and electronic assembly and other industries. At the same time, lead-free electronic products refer to electronic products (including raw and auxiliary materials, printed circuit boards, components, etc.) in the manufacturing, processing, coal bonding, assembly and use of products that do not contain lead components.
What Are the Basic Conditions for Lead-free Solder?
Lead-free solder to replace the traditional leaded coal, must meet or close to the main basic characteristics of leaded solder, including :D lead-free solder low eutectic (crystal point: no trace coal bonding "wet"), the reliability of the solder joint.
1. Low eutectic (crystal) point of lead-free solder
Considering the requirements of technological conditions such as welding and assembly of electronic products, the lead-free welding process cannot destroy the basic characteristics of components, assemblies and printed circuit board substrates in electronic products. Therefore, the low eutectic (crystal) point of lead-free solder should be as close as possible to the low eutectic (crystal) point 183C of traditional Sn-Pb alloy solder. Too high a low eutectic (low eutectic) point of lead-free solder will destroy the fundamental characteristics of components, assemblies, and printed circuit board substrates that have been developed over time in electronic products.
(1) Adaptability of components, assemblies and printed circuit board substrates at high temperature welding For a long time, the traditional Sn-Ph alloy solder system has been used for electronic products. Therefore, the heat resistance temperature of the components, assembly parts and printed circuit board substrate established by lead-free solder should be adapted to the welding conditions and requirements of the Sn-P alloy solder system. If the low eutectic (crystal) point of the lead-free solder is too high or much higher than 183C, it means that the welding temperature will also be much higher than the welding temperature of the Snp alloy solder. When the welding temperature of the lead-free solder exceeds the heat resistance temperature of the components, assemblies and online printed circuit board substrates, it means that the basic performance and reliability of the components, assemblies and printed circuit board substrates after welding and assembly cannot be guaranteed (maintained). At present, the best lead-free solder composition that can replace the traditional Sn-Pb alloy is Sm-Ag-Cu (SAC305) alloy system, whose low eutectic (crystal) point is 217C, which is higher than the low eutectic (crystal) melting point of Sn-Pb alloy solder is 34C.
Therefore, the welding temperature of Sn-Ag-Cu alloy solder is correspondingly higher by 20 ~40C. In order to adapt to the improvement of the low eutectic (crystal) point of lead-free solder, some few components, assembly parts and printed circuit board substrates with poor heat resistance should be improved and improved in time. For example, the common FR-4 substrate used in conventional printed circuit board substrates has a solution temperature of epoxy resin (Z;). Too low, mostly about 310C, must be improved and raised to about 350C, in order to meet the current requirements of ship-free solder welding conditions. For components, assemblies and PCB substrates with poor heat resistance, lead-free solder with a lower eutectic (crystal) point than the traditional Sn-Pb solder system can be used for welding, such as the Sn-Bi (58%) alloy solder with a low eutectic (crystal) point of 139C. However, due to the performance of Sn-Bi alloy solder, it is only suitable for low-grade, low-grade or low-grade electronic products with low reliability requirements.
(2) The adaptability of welding equipment and facilities to the low eutectic (crystal) point of lead-free solder at high temperature coal connection is established with the welding temperature and conditions of the Sn-Pb alloy solder. The art comes from the inevitable dimension of the heating temperature and time before the welding, the highest temperature and time of welding. This means that the welding of Mingti Bay without solder has no thermal performance, and even corrosion resistance (such as lead-free solder will obviously corrode the stainless tank, so it is necessary to use chin steel materials, etc.) and the corresponding facility conditions.
What Is Weldability of Lead-free Solder?
2. From the basic requirements of the welding process conditions of electronic products, the most important thing is to require lead-free solder to have good weldability. That is to say, the lead-free solder fused at welding temperature should have good wettability to the non-device pins (or bumps, etc.) and the pad (pad) on the printed circuit structure. Only good wettability can get a good welding point, which is very important.
The weldability of lead-free solder refers to its wettability at welding temperature. The wettability of lead-free solder at welding temperature is determined by the size of its surface tension, the greater the surface tension, the worse the wettability, the worse the weldability. Therefore, the surface tension of lead-free solder at welding temperature should be close to the surface tension of traditional Sn-Pb solder at welding temperature to ensure the wettability of lead-free solder at welding temperature, so as to ensure its weldability. Although increasing the welding temperature can reduce the surface tension of lead-free solder and improve the wettability. However, too high a processing temperature and welding temperature for the overall reliability of electronic products is very unfavorable. The addition of flux can improve the surface tension and weldability of welding, but the effect of flux is very limited [it has been used in the welding of traditional Sn-Pb solder, and it is impossible to reduce the surface tension. On the contrary, the higher welding temperature of lead-free solder will destroy the flux (such as thermal decomposition or volatilization) and lose the effect of flux in reducing the surface tension. Therefore, it is necessary to develop and use lead-free fluxes that are more resistant to high temperature, such as high temperature fluxes above 300C. The size of the surface tension or weldability mainly depends on the composition and characteristics of the lead-free solder itself.
3. Reliability of lead-free solder joints
There are many factors affecting the reliability of electronic products, and the reliability of the solder joint formed by no solder is one of the most important because of the cage pick bag according to the inert canister Ai Shanron waste bag
(1) The thermal fatigue strength of solder joints
The availability of solder joints is determined by the mechanical and physical characteristics of the solder itself, especially the resistance (resistance) of the solder joints formed by the solder. That is to say, the solder should not only be able to form a good (interface) bonding force with the pin of the piece and the pad (pad) metal surface on the printed circuit board, but also the solder itself should have good thermal fatigue resistance, so that the solder joint can have good reliability. Because electronic products in the welding and use of the process, the solder joint is always constantly subjected to thermal shock, can not avoid the occurrence of "thermal expansion" and "cold contraction", coupled with the component pins and other thermal expansion coefficient (CTE) and printed circuit board, Y direction of the thermal expansion coefficient there is a large difference between. The solder layer in the solder joint must be "thermal expansion" or "cold contraction" to form residual stress (commonly known as thermal stress). When the magnitude of this residual stress exceeds the heat resistance fatigue strength or bonding force of the solder, the solder at the solder joint will fracture, thereby reducing the reliability of the coal point
(2) The bonding strength of the solder at the solder joint
The bonding strength of the solder at the solder joint refers to the bonding strength between the metal surface of the component pin and the solder, and between the solder and the printed circuit board solder pad (to be exact, it should be the metal surface on the printed circuit board solder pad, which can be Cu.Au, Sn, Ag, Ni, etc.). The bonding force of solder at the solder joint refers to the bonding strength and the volume of the bonding area between the metal surface of the component pin and the solder, between the solder and the printed circuit board solder pad. Similarly, the residual stress or thermal stress caused by "thermal expansion" and "cold contraction" during welding and subsequent use due to the difference in the coefficient of thermal expansion at the solder joint), when this residual stress is not less than the binding force between the lead metal surface of the component and the solder, or the binding force between the solder and the metal surface of the printed circuit board solder pad, At the metal surface of the component pin of the solder joint or on the metal surface of the printed circuit board solder pad, the peeling phenomenon will occur, which affects the reliability.
(3) The integrity of the solder joint (wettability)
The integrity of the solder joint refers to the degree of welding defects at the solder joint. The welding defects at the solder joints are related to the solder type, composition and production (equipment, operation, etc.) conditions. Welding defects mainly depend on the physical characteristics of the solder itself, in particular the size of the surface tension (or wettability) of the solder at welding temperature. As mentioned above, the greater the surface tension of the solder during welding, the worse the wetness of the solder, the worse the integrity of the solder joint, such as the solder joint is not full, hollow, peeling, brittle and so on. Due to the large surface tension of lead-free solder, high welding temperature, long time and fast cooling speed after welding, the probability and degree of these defects are larger.
(4) The influence of intermetallic compounds
In the high-temperature welding process, the surface metal or the surface coated metal at the welding interface will melt into the molten solder, and form intermetallic compounds, such as Cu,Sns, Cu,Sn; NiSn4, Au; Sn(Cu,Ni)Sn, etc. The thickness (or number) of these intermetallic compounds at the interface will change with the temperature, welding methods and times. At the same time, some of these intermetallic compounds are weldable (e.g. Cu,Sng) and some are non-weldable (e.g. Cu,Sn;). . If Ni,Sna, (Cu,Ni)Sn are present at the same time, the internal stress (lattice dislocation, etc.) of the structure will be generated due to the different structures of the two intermetallic compounds at the interface, which will affect the reliability. Also, when Au; When the mass fraction of Sn exceeds 3%, brittle solder joints can be formed, which reduces the welding reliability.
Reliability of PCB When Soldering with Lead-free Solder
Because NUCCO requires higher preheating leakage, programmed connection temperature, longer high temperature contact time and logical cooling rate, the printed circuit board substrate will be subjected to greater (high) thermal shock and thermal stress than the traditional 5 coal system welding, which will also bring greater damage to the printed circuit board substrate, and the result will inevitably affect the reliability of the printed circuit board substrate. The impact of lead-free solder on the reliability of conventional printed circuit board substrate during welding is mainly manifested in five aspects printed circuit board substrate delamination, cracks, discoloration, etc. :@ layer cracks, disconnects, and even dips (similar to concave shrinkage) with the connected through hole; @ Pad (connecting plate) warping, falling off, printed circuit board substrate, warping; Conductive anode wire (CAF) phenomenon is more likely to occur. The hazards of these five aspects are directly proportional to heat (temperature), so the degree of harm will be higher and greater than the probability of damage caused by traditional Sn-Pl solder during welding. These hazards are not only the requirements for copper-clad plates, but also the challenges posed to the printed circuit board substrate.
(1) PCB substrate layering, cracks and discoloration, etc. The degree of PCB substrate layering, cracks and discoloration is directly proportional to heat. The welding temperature of lead-free solder is 20 ~40C higher than that of traditional Sn-Pb solder, and the residence time in high temperature welding (molten state) is 1/3 ~1/2 longer and the cooling speed is faster. This is prone to the following problems. Due to the difference in the coefficient of thermal expansion of the materials in the substrate, it is easier to layer bubbles between the layers of the conventional printed circuit board substrate, especially between the semi-cured sheet and the copper clad laminate substrate (including conductive graphics) in the multi-layer printed circuit board.
Microcracks occur between the glass fiber cloth and the resin or the inner layer resin in the substrate medium layer, which is due to the CTE of the glass fiber cloth (5 x10- ~7 x10-C-) and the coefficient of thermal expansion of the resin (conventional epoxy resin at a temperature less than T, the coefficient of thermal expansion is about 80 x10-6C, and when the temperature is greater than or equal to 7, the coefficient of thermal expansion is about 80 x10-6C. Its coefficient of thermal expansion will exceed 200 x10-c -) difference, Or is caused by the difference between the coefficient of thermal expansion of copper foil (coefficient of thermal expansion of 17x10-6C-') and the dielectric layer (coefficient of thermal expansion of 14 x10- ~17 x10-c -) or even the coefficient of thermal expansion of copper clad laminate substrate and semi-cured sheet (that is, mainly the difference between the "new" and "old" dielectric layer), etc. It may also be related to the lower decomposition temperature (T) of the resin, 3 the surface discoloration of the printed circuit board substrate (a symbol of the beginning of carbonization), which indicates that the structure of the resin has changed or the decomposition phenomenon has occurred under high temperature welding.
(2) The cracks, disconnections and stripping of the connecting through holes between layers are reliability problems caused by the difference in thermal expansion coefficient between the dielectric layer in the substrate and the copper coating through holes. The difference is that the difference in the coefficient of thermal expansion is mainly caused by the large difference in the coefficient of thermal expansion between the resin and the copper plating layer in the Z direction. The metallographic microsection of the printed circuit board shows that the problem of interlayer connection through holes mainly occurs when PCB is disconnected from the through hole copper coating at the 2nd and (n-1) layers, because the copper binding in the multi-layer printed circuit board substrate at these two connections is poor (compared with the outermost layer, because the outermost layer has thicker copper protection) and the second largest expansion. Of course, it is also the largest difference in the coefficient of thermal expansion; 2 Local cracks in the inner wall of the hole, most of which occur in the hole where the coating has defects, such as holes, impurities or places where the copper plating layer is thin; 3 Annular disconnection (cracking) occurs somewhere in the inner wall of the hole, mainly due to the uneven thickness of the copper coating in the hole (often occurring at the thinnest point), especially in the case of conventional DC plating. Of course, these three defects may also be due to the low ductility of the copper coating (such as when the ductility of the copper coating is less than 12%), which aggravates the probability and degree of these defects under the welding conditions of lead-free solder.
(3) Pad warping and falling off. When welding with lead-free solder, the pad on the printed circuit board will have a greater probability of warping and falling off (see Figure 16-8 and Figure 16-9). According to the research report, there are two main reasons for the warping and falling off of the pad :@ Under the impact of high heat (high temperature welding), high thermal stress caused by the difference in the thermal expansion coefficient of different materials (copper and resin), which means that high thermal stress (note, This refers to the high freezing point and rapid cooling rate of lead-free solder after welding) has exceeded the bonding force between the copper foil and the resin (especially when the high-density small pad and narrow ring width, the warping is more serious, and the copper foil of the pad has a higher temperature (copper has high thermal conductivity and high heat transfer rate), so that the resin surface under the pad has a higher temperature. Thus, the tree looks (especially the decomposition temperature of conventional epoxy resins, which is low, i.e. =310 320) due to local high temperature # solution. Other reasons for pad warping and falling off, such as the grade and performance of the copper clad box laminate substrate, the processing of the printed circuit board, etc.
(4) The printed circuit board substrate warping and twisting regardless of the ordinary single and double sided printed circuit board, or multi-layer printed circuit board, the high-temperature welding of lead-free solder will form greater warping and warping. This is because the welding of lead-free solder must be carried out under higher temperature and longer time conditions, coupled with the need for faster cooling rate and higher freezing point (the same as the low eutectic point) after welding, so that the thermal expansion coefficient of various materials inside the overall printed circuit board substrate is more different (note, This refers to the result of the high freezing point and rapid cooling temperature of the lead-free solder after welding), and the corresponding comprehensive thermal stress is also large, so in the "free" state of cooling down, it shows greater warpage and distortion.
Conductive Anodic Filament (CAF) Conductive anodic filament (CAF) is a type of copper migration along the glass fiber of the laminate, which can cause a short circuit if not contained. There are not many researches and reports on whether welding with lead-free solder will produce conductive anode wires with higher probability. However, from the mechanism of the generation of conductive anode wires, it can be known that the conditions for its production are :D there are mobile ions (can be internal or external); @ Humid (moisture, moisture, solution, etc.) conditions; The voltage that forms the electrode; The formation of channels, such as cracks, separation or surface contamination in the dielectric layer between conductive layers (or holes, lines).
Obviously, lead-free solder requires higher welding temperature and longer welding time, so that the probability and degree of defects (channels forming conductive anode wires) in the welding of the printed circuit board substrate is greater, which undoubtedly increases the probability of the formation of conductive anode wires. Under the development trend of printed circuit boards towards high density, the spacing between the through-hole and the through-hole, the wire and the wire, the layer and the layer (the medium layer is thinner and thinner) is getting smaller and smaller. The probability of conducting anode wires on high-density printed circuit boards also increases accordingly. Therefore, in the background of the development of printed circuit boards for high-density development of lead-free solder welding, the thermal problem of conductive anode wire should be paid attention to.
Reference
He Wei, PCB Basic Electrical Information Science and Technology, China Machine Press,345-349
PCB Knowledge ⋅ 12/23/2024 14:38